Independence of Cf-10 and Cf-12

Laterrot, H. and Moretti, A.

Among the sources of resistance to Fulvia fulva (= Cladosporium fulvum) which were exposed to more than a hundred isolates of the fungus, 2 lines received from E.A. Kerr in 1980 show a similar reaction which suggests the existence of an allelic relationship between the resistance factors of these 2 lines. The lines concerned are Ontario 792 (Cf-10) and Ontario 798 (Cf-12).

We carried out an allelism test, the results of which are given in Table 1. The test was carried out using a Cladosporium isolate belonging to race 0 and which was isolated in 1986 from open field grown tomatoes at Sarrians, in south-eastern France. This isolate is highly sporulant. Three pairs of Ontario 792 and Ontario 798 plants served as the basis of the test which can thus be considered as covering 3 repetitions.

Out of the 178 F2 plants (ONT 792 x ONT 798), 10 susceptible plants were observed. Thus the two factors are not allelic and these results suggest that the factors are independent (X^2 = 0.11; P = 0.75, taking as hypothesis 15 resistant plants : 1 susceptible plant), contrary to the deductions which can be drawn from the notes of Kanwar et al. (1980a, b), which were questioned by Kerr (1982).

Table 1 : Response of plant populations and lines after inoculation with a race 0 Cladosporium isolate

_____________________________________________________________
Populations or lines        Number of plants by class
                           ____________________________
                            I   B    BS   S    SS  SSS  TOTAL
_____________________________________________________________
F1 (ONT 792 x ONT 798) 1   16   -    -    -    -    -     16
F1 (ONT 792 x ONT 798) 2   16   -    -    -    -    -     16
F1 (ONT 792 x ONT 798) 3    7   -    -    -    -    -      7
F2 (ONT 792 x ONT 798) 1   55   1    -    -    -    4     60
F2 (ONT 792 x ONT 798) 2   52   4    1    -    -    3     60
F2 (ONT 792 x ONT 798) 3   54   -    1    -    1    2     58
Ontario 792 (Cf-10)        15   1    -    -    -    -     16
Ontario 798 (Cf-12)         7   4    -    -    -    -     11
Monalbo (susceptible line)  -   -    -    -    -   13     13
_____________________________________________________________
Class of attack:  I   : no symptoms
                  B   : white specks with abundant mycelium
                  BS  : the same as B plus some sporulation
                  S   : moderate sporulation
                  SS  : heavy sporulation
                  SSS : very heavy sporulation
Literature cited :

Kanwar, J.S., E.A. Kerr and P.M. Harney 1980 a. TGC Report 30. 20-21

Kanwar, J.S., E.A. Kerr and P.M. Harney 1980 b. TGC Report 30 : 22-23

Kerr E.A., 1982. TGC Report 32 : 19